Foothill
← Decision log

Collision Repair

Bent front doors

2023 Ford F-150 Tremor · 5.0L V8

Options considered

  • Ford (OEM, Motorcraft) via American Fleet MD

    Front door shells, left and right, Oxford White, new take-off

    Delivered 29 Sep 2026 — one door hung so far

  • J and T Auto Parts, Marion NC (used)

    Complete used front doors, pair

  • Knox Auto Parts, Knoxville (used)

    Complete used front doors, pair

  • Body shop

    Repair the existing door

What this turns on

Both front doors were damaged. On the passenger side the hit landed on the hemmed trailing edge: rolled outward, creased into the lower rear corner, paint scraped to bare metal. What makes this worth writing down is what does not exist. Bare front door shells are effectively absent from the salvage network, which lists complete doors, and a search for a Tremor shell turns out to be the wrong search: the 2021-2025 F-150 front shell is one part across every trim but Raptor, and it is shared with the 2023-2025 Super Duty.

Front door shells, left and right, Oxford White, new take-off

Chosen

Ford (OEM, Motorcraft) via American Fleet MD

Received

Delivered 29 Sep 2026 — one door hung so far

Part number: ML3Z-1620124-E (RH) / ML3Z-1620125 (LH)

Why this option

The 2021-on F-150 door skin is aluminum, and the damage sits at the hem. Work-hardened aluminum at a bonded fold cracks rather than straightens, so a body-shop repair was ruled out before it was priced. A bare shell in the factory white was $550 a side, and the seller's willingness to put both on one pallet is what made the pair affordable: a single shell shipped alone was $899.99 landed, the pair came to $1,618.61 with tax.

Trade-offs

The listing carried no written description and the seller never defined what 'New other' meant, which is why the purchase stayed on eBay for the returns cover. Glass, regulators, latches, handles, harnesses and trim all transfer from the old doors. A bent door usually means the opening took load, so the aperture gets measured before each shell is hung. Cosmetics are deferred to next year's repaint; bare aluminum does not rust, so that is safe.

Photography

Bench photo once it arrives
As delivered
Added after fitting
Installed
Added once it's been lived with
In use

What it actually cost

Part
$1,100
Shipping
$381.56
Tax
$137.05
All-in
$1,618.61

eBay charged freight per item, $699.98 for the pair; the seller refunded $347.87 the next morning so both shells travelled on one pallet. Shipping and tax are shown net of that refund.

Installation

Hands-on time
2.5 hours

Complete used front doors, pair

J and T Auto Parts, Marion NC (used)

Researching

Why this option

One 2021 white donor carrying both front doors, Grade A, at $1,000 a side; a complete door brings glass, regulators and hardware with it.

Where it currently stands

$2,000 for the pair before a 240-mile round trip, and the paint code was not listed, so Oxford White against Star White would have had to be confirmed in person. The bare shells landed for less than one of these doors.

What it actually cost

Not purchased yet — no cost recorded.

Cost, installation notes, and a verdict will be added here once this part is bought and fitted.

Complete used front doors, pair

Knox Auto Parts, Knoxville (used)

Researching

Why this option

Eight miles away, with a white 2022 donor holding both doors.

Where it currently stands

Listed at $1,725 and $1,775 a side, priced as undamaged. More than three times the cost of the shells.

What it actually cost

Not purchased yet — no cost recorded.

Cost, installation notes, and a verdict will be added here once this part is bought and fitted.

Repair the existing door

Body shop

Researching

Why this option

The usual answer to a creased door, and the cheapest if the metal cooperates.

Where it currently stands

Not attempted. The damage sits on the hem of an aluminum skin, which is already yielded and work-hardened at the fold; it cracks instead of coming back.

What it actually cost

Not purchased yet — no cost recorded.

Cost, installation notes, and a verdict will be added here once this part is bought and fitted.

Vehicle this applies to

Fitment notes here are specific to this truck's configuration. Check yours before ordering.

Vehicle
2023 Ford F-150 Tremor
Engine
5.0L V8
Cab
SuperCrew
Bed
5.5 ft
Rear axle
3.73
Factory options
Adaptive cruise, moonroof
Target tire size
35 in
Tow load
6,500 lb Airstream
Front end
Gen 3 Raptor-spec conversion — FiberwerX carbon panels, OEM Raptor grille, ADD bumpers
Parts fitment
Gen 3 Raptor spec
Title
Salvage — front-end impact (both front corners), rear impact, both headlights, rear leaf springs